Is exposing the mistakes of the astray present day groups from Jarh wa Ta'deel?
Question:
"Dear virtuous Shaykh, may Allah grant you success, the questioner says: "Is speaking about the present day groups by exposing their mistakes, and also about individuals who oppose the fundamentals and the methodology of the Salaf, considered as being from the required Jarh wa Ta'deel?"
Answer:
"How many times have we told you that Jarh wa Ta'deel is from the sciences of the chain of narration; from the sciences of Hadeeth and that the scholars of Hadeeth are the only ones in charge over it?!
And as for refuting the opposer then this is not from Jarh wa Ta'deel. This is from clarifying the truth, from clarifying the truth and refuting the falsehood. It is not out of Jarh wa Ta'deel and not because the aim is to perform Jarh on the refuted. We only clarify the truth and we clarify the mistake of the mistaken. Our aim are not the individuals in order for him to even say that this is Jarh wa Ta'deel. Yes."
Shaykh Saalih bin Fawzaan Al-Fawzaan, may Allah preserve him
Translated by 'Abdurrahīm Ibn Muhammad Al-Hadhramī.
Published on Salafi-Dawah.com.
Use the player below or download the MP3 here.
"Dear virtuous Shaykh, may Allah grant you success, the questioner says: "Is speaking about the present day groups by exposing their mistakes, and also about individuals who oppose the fundamentals and the methodology of the Salaf, considered as being from the required Jarh wa Ta'deel?"
Answer:
"How many times have we told you that Jarh wa Ta'deel is from the sciences of the chain of narration; from the sciences of Hadeeth and that the scholars of Hadeeth are the only ones in charge over it?!
And as for refuting the opposer then this is not from Jarh wa Ta'deel. This is from clarifying the truth, from clarifying the truth and refuting the falsehood. It is not out of Jarh wa Ta'deel and not because the aim is to perform Jarh on the refuted. We only clarify the truth and we clarify the mistake of the mistaken. Our aim are not the individuals in order for him to even say that this is Jarh wa Ta'deel. Yes."
Shaykh Saalih bin Fawzaan Al-Fawzaan, may Allah preserve him
Translated by 'Abdurrahīm Ibn Muhammad Al-Hadhramī.
Published on Salafi-Dawah.com.
Use the player below or download the MP3 here.
السؤال: فضيلة الشيخ وفقكم الله يقول السائل هل يعتبر الكلام في الأحزاب المعاصرة بكشف معايبهم وكذلك الأفراد الذين يخالفون أصول ومنهج السلف هل يعتبر هذا من الجرح والتعديل المطلوب؟
الجواب: الجرح والتعديل قلنا لكم كم مرة أنه من علوم الإسناد من علوم الحديث ولا يتولاه إلا المحدثون. أما الرد على المخالف هذا ما هو من الجرح والتعديل. هذا من بيان الحق. من بيان الحق ورد الباطل ما هو من باب الجرح والتعديل ولا لأن الغرض بالمردود عليه أن نجرحه لا نحن نبين الحق فقط ونبين خطأ المخطئ ولا لنا غرض في الأشخاص حتى يقول جرح وتعديل. نعم
salafi-dawah.com الحمد لله. تم هذا التفريغ من قبل موقع
الجواب: الجرح والتعديل قلنا لكم كم مرة أنه من علوم الإسناد من علوم الحديث ولا يتولاه إلا المحدثون. أما الرد على المخالف هذا ما هو من الجرح والتعديل. هذا من بيان الحق. من بيان الحق ورد الباطل ما هو من باب الجرح والتعديل ولا لأن الغرض بالمردود عليه أن نجرحه لا نحن نبين الحق فقط ونبين خطأ المخطئ ولا لنا غرض في الأشخاص حتى يقول جرح وتعديل. نعم
salafi-dawah.com الحمد لله. تم هذا التفريغ من قبل موقع