It is not correct to claim that the matter of leaving off all actions is a matter of difference of opinion between Ahlus-Sunnah!
Question (read by the shaykh):
“Lately there has appeared in the internet a book called ‘Dalaa’il al-Burhaan’, wherein the author states that the matter of leaving off all actions is a matter of difference of opinion between Ahlus-Sunnah, and that criticism or the ruling of tabdee' (declaring someone to be an innovator) is therefore impermissible. So what is your reply?”
Answer:
“This in reality is the speech of the Murji’ah. This speech is from the Murji’ah, the ones who make actions into a 'perfection of Imaan' and not as a 'condition for the soundness of Imaan’.
In other words, they say that if someone believes with his heart, (but) he doesn’t pray and he doesn’t fast, and he doesn’t perform ‘Umrah and Hajj, and he commits forbidden matters; that he is a complete believer. And that is not correct!”
Shaykh 'Abdullaah al-Ghudayyaan, may Allah have mercy upon him
Translated by Salafi-Dawah.com.
Use the player below or download the MP3 here.
“Lately there has appeared in the internet a book called ‘Dalaa’il al-Burhaan’, wherein the author states that the matter of leaving off all actions is a matter of difference of opinion between Ahlus-Sunnah, and that criticism or the ruling of tabdee' (declaring someone to be an innovator) is therefore impermissible. So what is your reply?”
Answer:
“This in reality is the speech of the Murji’ah. This speech is from the Murji’ah, the ones who make actions into a 'perfection of Imaan' and not as a 'condition for the soundness of Imaan’.
In other words, they say that if someone believes with his heart, (but) he doesn’t pray and he doesn’t fast, and he doesn’t perform ‘Umrah and Hajj, and he commits forbidden matters; that he is a complete believer. And that is not correct!”
Shaykh 'Abdullaah al-Ghudayyaan, may Allah have mercy upon him
Translated by Salafi-Dawah.com.
Use the player below or download the MP3 here.
:السؤال
ظهر في هذه الأيام كتاب في شبكة الإنترنت بعنوان ( دلائل البرهان ) ، يُقرّرُ فيه كاتبه أن تارك أعمال الجوارح مسألة خلافية بين أهل السنة فلا يجوز الإنكار والتبديع فما قولكم؟
:الشيخ الغديان
هذا في الواقع هو قول المرجئة ، هذا قول المرجئة الذين يجعلون الأعمال مُكملة وليست شرطاً في صحة الإيمان ؛ يعني يقولون : إذا آمن الإنسان بقلبه ، ما صلى ، ولا صام ولا اعتمر ، ولا حج ، وفعل المحرمات هذا مؤمن تماما ً، وهذا ما هو صحيح
ظهر في هذه الأيام كتاب في شبكة الإنترنت بعنوان ( دلائل البرهان ) ، يُقرّرُ فيه كاتبه أن تارك أعمال الجوارح مسألة خلافية بين أهل السنة فلا يجوز الإنكار والتبديع فما قولكم؟
:الشيخ الغديان
هذا في الواقع هو قول المرجئة ، هذا قول المرجئة الذين يجعلون الأعمال مُكملة وليست شرطاً في صحة الإيمان ؛ يعني يقولون : إذا آمن الإنسان بقلبه ، ما صلى ، ولا صام ولا اعتمر ، ولا حج ، وفعل المحرمات هذا مؤمن تماما ً، وهذا ما هو صحيح
